Maybe not so hopelessThe December conference in Copenhagen on climate change was supposed to be the last change for humanity to save itself from its own contribution to global warming and catastrophic climate change. This view is based on an assumption that emissions in the future would continue to grow as they have in the past. But what if the future is one of contraction and disorganisation anyway, asks Brian Davey in a thought provoking article for “openDemocracy”.
He argues the possibility that human society might be entering a future in which its economic, organisational and lifestyle environment might look dramatically different to what we have become used to.
In the lead up to Copenhagen it was repeatedly said that this was "the last change to save the climate". This idea was constructed on an assumption about "business as usual". If emissions continue to grow on current trends then, with little time left to put on the brakes and decarbonise the global economy at a sufficient rate, the task appears to be totally unfeasible.
With many scientists credibly arguing that we are already over the safe limit for greenhouse gas concentrations in the atmosphere, this may be true. There is now a good case that we need to go beyond decarbonising in the economy to actually finding technologies and processes to take CO2 that is already in the atmosphere out again.
So is the situation now quite hopeless? Perhaps so, but perhaps not. A reason for being at least a little hopeful is the questionable assumption of what "business as usual" will be like. The common assumption is that the global economy will continue to grow as it has done over the last few decades. But is this assumption true in the light of peak oil and peak gas, Davey asks as he points out that some dramatic enforced changes in the present global energy regime might be coming humanity’s way.
He points out that during the last year global emissions did not grow as the economy slid into recession. One way of constructing the events of the last year are that rising energy prices played a major role in undermining many people’s ability to service their debts. A reckless financial system was undermined. Of course there was more to the financial crisis and the recession than merely a rise in energy and food prices, but that was surely an important part of the crisis. There is good reason to believe that the energy crisis has only just begun, he argues.
There might be a near term peak in global oils supplies at hand. If correct, there is an energy crunch down the tracks as the real economy picks up with resultant rising energy prices and business as usual emissions will not be quite the same as projected in some studies.
According to Davey, the future might not be one of continued expansion, but one of contraction and disorganisation as in line with the thesis of archaeologist Joseph Tainers' that our society has simply become too complex for governing, management and technical arrangements of society to cope. The future is likely to be one of considerable disorganisation.
He concludes,"The current discourse about the aftermath of Copenhagen assumes a future that is merely a projection of the past. Nothing could be further from the truth. Humanity has now reached the limits of economic growth. Climate change is just one manifestation of this. Having overshot and overused natural capital humanity stands before turbulent times.
"The complex governance and management arrangements underpinned by plenty cheap energy will not be up to dealing with the problems we face. A totally different politics and totally different lifestyles are necessary if humanity is to have any chance of seeing out the century.
"At the same time, the future may yet prove malleable than we think. Whether this is really cause for hope after Copenhagen remains to be seen. But let us at least discuss the real issues rather than the banalities of the official narrative." (To read Davey's full article, click here.)
- 23/03/2012 10:42 - Climbing costs of climate change
- 13/02/2012 08:31 - Climate change
- 08/02/2012 09:52 - Green growth requires a green engine
- 12/12/2011 09:59 - COP 17
- 30/11/2011 10:25 - Keeping the economic arteries clean
- 06/04/2010 07:28 - Energy and climate change
- 29/03/2010 07:32 - Climate Change
- 09/03/2010 08:49 - Disaster management
- 01/02/2010 10:00 - Active participation
- 19/01/2010 08:30 - Disaster awaits South Africa
- 25/11/2009 10:37 - Climate change – expect some hot air
Profile
Read more... |
SITA Service Management Centre supports the 2011 local government electionsThe State Information Technology Agency (SITA) Service Management Centre (SMC) has a customer-orientated and services focused approach in running its service management services and business process outsourcing (BPO) services, which contributes toward becoming more competitive in its strategy. Read more... | ||
For a long time the Ekurhuleni region has been synonymous with manufacturing earning it the nickname 'Africa's manufacturing hub'- and it still is, but this is certainly not all that the area has to offer. This has become more apparent thanks to the 2010 world cup.
Read more... |
Dedicated to providing superior investment performance and service excellence Established in 1974, Allan Gray Limited is the largest privately owned investment management firm in Southern Africa. Its clients comprise institutional investors, principally retirement funds, medical aid schemes and endowments, and individuals. Clients invest through either segregated accounts or collective investment funds. Read more... | ||
Amatola Water is a state-owned, non-profit business enterprise accountable to the Minister of Water and Environmental Affairs, created jointly by national, provincial and local community stakeholders to serve as a multi-service, bulk water services provider. Its core aim is to assist local government in the effective development and sustainable provision of safe, reliable water supply and waste water services. Amatola Water is fully committed to improving the quality of people’s lives and recognises the challenges facing national, provincial and local government in the water sector. The eradication of water and sanitation backlogs is central to the supportive role that Amatola Water plays in this regard.Read more... |
Anglo Platinum Limited is listed on the JSE Limited and is the sole listed entity for the Group. It has a secondary listing on the London Stock Exchange. International depositary receipts for the Company's shares are listed on the Brussels bourse. The Group's main operating mines include Rustenburg Platinum Mines¹ (RPM) Rustenburg Section, Amandelbult Section and Union Section (85% owned), as well as Potgietersrust Platinums Limited (PPRust) (now Mogalakwena Section), Twickenham and Lebowa Platinum Mines Limited (LPM). Read more... | ||
21 - 27 March 2011 National Water Week is an annual event celebrated in March to coincide with the United Nations World Water Day. This year is no exception as it will be celebrated from 21 – 27 March 2011.
Read more... |
Overview The Industrial Development Corporation of South Africa Ltd (IDC) is a self-financing, national Development Finance Institution (DFI). It was established in 1940 to promote economic growth and industrial development in South Africa. At the IDC we recognise the importance of a dynamic private sector in securing and stimulating rapid and sustainable economic growth, creating employment and reducing poverty. Read more... | ||
Mayor Mlaba continuously works on improving the eThekwini MunicipalityHaving been mayor since 1996, Obed Mlaba has enjoyed his tenure in this position at eThekwini Municipality. The last 15 years have been filled with both exciting times as well as challenges, but nothing has been able to sway his passion for the job. Read more... |
Absa Group Limited is one of South Africa's largest financial services organisations, serving personal, commercial and corporate customers in South Africa. The Group interacts with its customers through a combination of physical and electronic channels, offering a comprehensive range of banking services, (from basic products and services for the low-income personal market to customised solutions for the commercial and corporate markets), bancassurance and wealth management products and services. |



Upington rises as a symbol of progress in the Northern Cape.The expertise and sound governance of IIKhara Hais Municipality contribute to this prosperity.IIKhara Hais Municipality and the community are partners in this regard.
SITA Service Management Centre supports the 2011 local government elections
For a long time the Ekurhuleni region has been synonymous with manufacturing earning it the nickname 'Africa's manufacturing hub'- and it still is, but this is certainly not all that the area has to offer. This has become more apparent thanks to the 2010 world cup.

21 - 27 March 2011 National Water Week is an annual event celebrated in March to coincide with the United Nations World Water Day. This year is no exception as it will be celebrated from 21 – 27 March 2011.
Mayor Mlaba continuously works on improving the eThekwini Municipality











